A Comparative Review of Top Treasury Management Software

Finding the right treasury management software is a common pain point for finance teams.

This comparative review promises to cut through the confusion by evaluating the top solutions on the market today.

You'll get an unbiased look at leading options from Kyriba, Fusion, Oracle, QTM, and SAP, including key features, integration capabilities, and total cost of ownership. Most importantly, you'll learn how to match the right system with your organization's specific needs.

Navigating Treasury Management Software: An Introduction

Treasury management software has transformed how modern businesses handle critical financial operations. As opposed to relying on spreadsheets or legacy systems, treasury management platforms centralize key processes to optimize cash flow, payments, risk mitigation and more.

Leading providers have expanded the capabilities of these systems over the years. Today's solutions typically include robust accounting tools, cash forecasting, AP/AR automation, bank connectivity, and dashboards to track KPIs. This enables finance teams to manage working capital, purchasing, investments and global payments from a unified hub.

With the right treasury management software, businesses can streamline cumbersome workflows, ensure compliance, gain visibility across regions, and support data-driven decision making. The systems integrate with ERPs while consolidating data from banking partners worldwide. As a result, treasurers can spot patterns, simulate strategies and scale operations as their needs evolve.

Selecting the ideal platform depends on an organization's size, global footprint, industry, accounting methods and specific pain points. Comparing solutions from recognized providers is key. While basic functions overlap, the depth and flexibility of tools can vary greatly. Whether a business seeks enhanced automation, sophisticated analytics or robust bank integration, today's top treasury management systems accommodate specialized needs. The landscape improves yearly.

Businesses must clearly define feature requirements and onboard an intuitive, scalable provider that aligns with their vision. With the right foundation, treasury management software grants organizations the agility and insight to thrive in today's dynamic markets. The following sections explore what modern systems offer and how leaders can determine the best fit.

Which software on treasury management are available?

There are several excellent treasury management software solutions available to effectively streamline financial operations. HighRadius, SAP Treasury and Risk Management, Treasury, Kyriba, Coupa, GTreasury, Trovata, and CashAnalytics are among the top options worth considering.

These systems provide a range of capabilities including cash flow forecasting, payments, collections, reconciliation, accounting, reporting, analytics, and more. They leverage automation and AI to optimize liquidity and cash positions. Integration with ERPs like NetSuite and SAP provide additional back-office visibility.

When evaluating solutions, key aspects to analyze are core treasury functionality, ease of use, data and system security, scalability, implementation approach, total cost of ownership, and customer support. Other considerations are industry specialization, global capabilities, and having an open API architecture for custom integrations.

By correctly identifying organizational needs and finding the best-fit provider, companies can transform treasury operations to be more data-driven, efficient, and strategically positioned to enable business growth. The systems above represent leading options capable of delivering significant long-term value.

How do I choose a treasury management system?

Choosing the right treasury management system is crucial for optimizing cash management and ensuring financial stability. Here are some key steps to select the best system for your needs:

Assess Needs and Goals

First, analyze your organization's specific treasury requirements - what features are essential versus nice to have? Prioritize capabilities like cash positioning, payments, risk management based on your operations and strategic goals. Defining needs upfront allows comparing systems accurately.

Examine Features and Functionality

Research functionality of top treasury management systems. Compare capabilities like bank account administration, cash forecasting, liquidity analysis. Shortlist tools offering features meeting your must-haves determined from initial needs assessment. Verify the shortlisted systems provide the depth of functionality required.

Evaluate Ease of Use

Treasury teams will heavily utilize the selected system daily. An intuitive, easy-to-use interface ensures high adoption across the organization. Assess the UI, navigation, reporting, and search - less training/ramp-up time increases productivity. Complex systems lead to limited usage and value realization.

Focusing on key criteria ensures you select the treasury management platform best fitting your needs. Leveraging the system's full capabilities unlocks significant efficiency gains for treasury teams through process optimization and strategic financial management. Choose wisely after thorough evaluations.

Who are Kyriba competitors?

Kyriba, a leader in cloud treasury and finance solutions, has many competitors in the treasury management software space. Based on recent G2 community reviews, the top 10 Kyriba alternatives are:

Coupa

Coupa is a cloud-based spend management platform that received a 4.2 out of 5 star rating from 407 G2 reviews. While more focused on procurement, Coupa offers some treasury management capabilities like payments and cash flow forecasting.

SAP Treasury and Risk Management

SAP Treasury and Risk Management is an on-premise treasury management system from enterprise software giant SAP. It earned a 4.4 out of 5 rating from 17 G2 reviews, though adoption seems less widespread than other options.

GTreasury

GTreasury markets an integrated TMS supporting cash management, payments, risk management and more. It has a 3.9 out of 5 rating based on a smaller sample of 12 G2 reviews.

The other leading alternatives cited are Invoiced, Airbase, Stampli, BILL, Corpay Cross-Border, and Quantum Treasury. Each earned positive reviews from hundreds of users highlighting ease of use, automation, and collaboration benefits.

While none match Kyriba’s market share, these competitors offer comparable core cash and risk management capabilities. Businesses evaluating TMS solutions should review their unique functionalities, integrations, and configurability during the selection process. Consulting analyst reports from Gartner and similar firms can also help identify leaders in this space.

How much does a treasury management system cost?

Treasury management systems vary in pricing models and structures based on different factors like features offered, implementation, modules, integrations, and customization. However, most providers offer pricing tiers based on the size and complexity of the organization.

For small businesses with basic cash management needs, an entry-level system often starts around $1,000/year. Mid-size companies may pay $5,000-$20,000 annually depending on the level of automation and number of integrated bank accounts. Large enterprises with global operations and multi-entity roll-ups can expect to invest $100,000+ a year for a robust treasury management platform.

Additional costs also include:

• Implementation fees - Typically a one-time fee that covers deployment, configuration, testing, training and launching the system. Can range from 5% to 15% of total contract value.
• Professional services - Ongoing fees for support, maintenance, upgrades and custom enhancements. Around 22% of annual contract cost.
• Transaction-based pricing - Charges based on account or transaction volume are common for bank connectivity and reconciliation.

When evaluating options, consider required features, scalability needs, total cost of ownership vs return on investment, and provider reputation. Leveraging a subscription model also allows flexibility to scale system capabilities along with business growth over time. Discussing requirements with prospective vendors is key to finding the ideal long term treasury management solution.

sbb-itb-beb59a9

Top Treasury Management Systems: A Gartner-Inspired Analysis

Enterprise treasury management systems empower finance teams with control, visibility, and strategic decision support for their organization's cash flow operations. As the central nervous system for cash, liquidity, payments, and risk, selecting the right treasury management software is critical.

This analysis of top treasury management systems draws insights from Gartner's annual Magic Quadrant reports which evaluate providers based on completeness of vision and ability to execute.

Kyriba: The Forefront of Treasury Management

Kyriba delivers a leading cloud-based treasury management solution combining robust cash, risk, payments and working capital functionality on a unified platform.

With over 2,000 clients worldwide including many Fortune 500 companies, Kyriba is a recognized innovator, offering:

• Real-time cash visibility across accounts and entities
• Integrated cash forecasting and liquidity analysis
• Automated intercompany loans and netting
• Multi-bank connectivity and payments integration
• Customizable workflows and comprehensive security

Positioned as a Leader in Gartner’s Magic Quadrant, Kyriba is noted for its product capabilities, global customer base, and overall completeness of vision. For growing multinationals to large enterprises, Kyriba provides a modern and extensible treasury management system.

Fusion Treasury: Empowering Finance Operations

Fusion Treasury is a secure, cloud-based treasury and cash management solution gaining strong momentum with over 650 customers.

Designed for finance users with an intuitive interface, Fusion Treasury is recognized for:

• Streamlined daily cash management and tracking
• Flexible accounting configuration and reporting
• Automated bank communications for payments and reporting
• Integrated modules for managing risk, bank accounts, payments and more

An innovative offering with superb usability, Fusion Treasury appeals to enterprises seeking user-friendly financial systems. Continued platform enhancements solidify its status as an emerging treasury management leader.

Oracle Cash and Treasury Management: Integrated Financial Control

Part of Oracle’s robust ERP cloud platform, Oracle Cash Management centralizes treasury operations into an integrated suite with:

• Cash positioning, forecasting and investment management
• Streamlined bank account and payment tracking
• In-depth cash analytics and configurable reporting
• Interfaced modules for risk, bank connectivity, and more

Oracle has among the most mature product capabilities for cash and treasury management. The system shines providing financial control, visibility, and seamless ERP integration for organizations running Oracle Financials.

The Quantum Leap: QTM’s Treasury Management System

Quantum Treasury (QTM) delivers an innovative treasury system combining financial applications with secure cloud infrastructure tailored to each client's needs.

With strong growth, QTM is noted for:

• Intuitive portal simplifying daily treasury tasks
• Flexible accounting framework across entities
• Automated cash positioning and forecasting
• Integrated risk analytics, payments and bank connectivity

QTM's focus on usability, automation and infrastructure flexibility makes it appealing for treasury teams in diverse industries. Continued technology and product investment cement its position as an emerging treasury software leader.

SAP Treasury and Risk Management: A Robust Contender

SAP Treasury Management provides deep treasury functionality as part of SAP’s ERP suite. It enables organizations to:

• Optimize cash positions, liquidity and working capital
• Monitor financial risks across exposures
• Automate payment factory workflows
• Seamlessly integrate banking and trading platforms

SAP boasts very mature capabilities for automating treasury processes, providing integrated control over cash operations. However, functionality gaps exist in emerging areas like predictive analytics compared to niche solutions. Still SAP Treasury integration remains a top choice for many large corporates running SAP ERP.

What to Look for in a Treasury Management System

When assessing treasury management systems, it's crucial to carefully evaluate key factors that impact functionality, scalability, and long-term ROI. The optimal TMS solution for an organization depends heavily on its specific needs and use cases. However, most businesses should analyze systems based on core capabilities, configurability, supported integrations, and overall usability.

Core System Functionality

The core features of any TMS should facilitate efficient cash, liquidity, and risk management. Key areas of focus include:

Cash Forecasting and Visibility - Quality forecasting tools provide clear cash flow visibility to inform strategic decisions and identify potential shortfalls or surpluses proactively. Look for advanced AI and machine learning to improve accuracy over time.

Payments and Receivables - The system should efficiently handle high payment volumes, supporting ACH, wires, checks, and cards. Receivables management facilitates timely inbound collections.

Liquidity and Investment Management - TMS solutions should optimize utilization of cash and liquid assets to maximize returns while balancing financial risk. This enables smarter investment strategies aligned to policy limits.

Accounting System Integration - Seamless integration with major accounting systems like Oracle NetSuite streamlines reconciliation and reporting for real-time cash visibility.

Fraud and Security - With cash management, risk mitigation is paramount. Ensure the TMS leverages robust security to protect transactions and sensitive financial data.

Regulatory Compliance - An enterprise-grade TMS satisfies various regulations like ASC 842 lease accounting requirements or supports compliance initiatives in global operations.

Reporting and Analytics - Dynamic reporting and analytics provide actionable, audit-ready insights to inform strategic decisions on cash utilization, investments, forecasting assumptions and more.

Solution Configurability and Scalability

The optimal TMS adapts seamlessly to changing business needs. Seek solutions with flexible configuration options to match specific use cases without restricting future growth. While pre-configured editions have their purpose, customizable platforms based on company size and complexity are ideal for long-term scalability.

Integrations and Data Consolidation

As mentioned for accounting system integration, a robust TMS platform should consolidate data flows across banking partners, ERPs like NetSuite, HCM platforms, FX services, lease management systems and more. The leading solutions support native, bi-directional integrations for centralized visibility and enriched functionality.

Intuitive and Unified User Experience

Employee adoption is key to maximizing TMS ROI. Thus, an intuitive, unified interface provides easy access to features like approvals workflows, reporting, payments processing, forecasting tools, liquidity analysis and more. This enables seamless, secure collaboration between finance teams, AP clerks, department heads and others. Ideally, the TMS leverages cloud delivery with mobile optimization for on-the-go accessibility.

By focusing evaluations on these key areas, finance leaders can determine the most capable treasury management system for driving long-term efficiency, risk mitigation and strategic decision making across the cash conversion cycle. The best-fit solution depends on organizational maturity, existing infrastructure, use case complexity, and budget. However, configurability, seamless integrations, and an intuitive interface remain universal requirements for success.

Feature Showdown: Comparing Treasury Management Software

As banks and financial institutions seek to optimize cash flow and minimize risk, evaluating treasury management systems (TMS) has become an essential part of operations. With intricate regulatory requirements and complex infrastructures, choosing a TMS that meets specialized needs is critical.

This section will compare features and capabilities of leading options, providing key insights on system strengths and limitations.

Treasury Management Software for Banks: Compliance and Complexities

Banks face distinctive challenges in treasury management, including dynamic regulatory compliance, real-time liquidity analysis, and seamless integration across legacy systems. As such, banking-focused TMS solutions cater to these specific pain points.

For example, Kyriba's bank-centered TMS touts compliance readiness for regulations like ASC 842 and SOFR. With pre-configured reports, dashboards, and workflows, banks can readily adhere to shifting standards. Meanwhile, IT2 Treasury's specialized banking TMS highlights features like advanced liquidity analysis, real-time cash positioning, and automated bank statement processing to align with banks' daily operations.

By selecting systems purpose-built for banking, financial institutions gain responsive regulatory tools, robust cash flow insights, and streamlined integration with existing frameworks. This eliminates the need for custom-coding workarounds or third-party add-ons to achieve compliance and optimize liquidity.

Integration and Interoperability: Connecting with Existing Systems

Given complex existing technology stacks, banks require treasury systems that readily integrate across platforms. Modern TMS solutions leverage open APIs and configurable connectors to bridge data across core banking, ERP, accounting, trading, and other auxiliary systems.

For example, Quantum's iTMPlatform uses APIs to ingest data from source systems, centralizing information into a unified dashboard for cash, risk, and position visibility. With real-time data synced from banking systems, Quantum's TMS enables dynamic liquidity analysis and cash flow optimization.

Similarly, FIS Integrity's open architecture leverages APIs and SWIFT connectivity to embed within existing platforms, eliminating duplicate data entry. With capabilities to model complex global entity structures, Integrity readily aligns with intricate multinational banking frameworks.

As banks navigate interwoven legacy technology, configurable TMS integration enables centralized data analysis without demanding disruptive system overhauls. This empowers banks to unify insights across platforms for optimized treasury strategy.

Matching Treasury Solutions to Business Needs

As businesses grow and evolve, their treasury management needs change. The right treasury management system (TMS) can provide critical visibility, control, and efficiency for treasury teams. However, with many options on the market, it's important to match your business requirements to the strengths of different providers.

TMS Selection by Business Type

The optimal TMS depends heavily on your business model and specific treasury needs:

High-Growth Startups

Startups need agile systems that can scale rapidly. Cloud-based TMS platforms like Kyriba, TreasuryXpress, and Cashforce provide faster implementation and fewer IT requirements. Key features include:

• Automated bank connectivity for real-time cash visibility
• Flexible, scalable SaaS delivery model
• Cash forecasting and liquidity analysis

For example, when multi-channel retailer Boohoo experienced explosive growth, they selected Kyriba's TMS to consolidate international treasury operations, improve visibility, and support expansion.

Complex Multinationals

Large cap companies often have decentralized business units, complex banking needs, and regulatory requirements. They benefit from comprehensive TMS suites like FIS Integrity, FIS Quantum, and Murex, which offer:

• Sophisticated cash, risk, and treasury management
• Integrated ERP connectivity
• International and multi-entity support

As a global industrial manufacturer operating across 150 countries, Eaton worked to consolidate treasury systems onto FIS' Integrity platform. This delivered improved oversight and control over global cash and risk.

Middle Market Businesses

Mid-sized companies need to balance functional needs with overhead costs. Providers like CashAnalytics, GTreasury, and Finastra offer TMS solutions focused on serving this segment with functionality like:

• Cash flow and in-house bank management
• Simple and flexible SaaS platforms
• Integrations with commonly used ERPs

For example, when office technology company ABCOM needed to upgrade legacy treasury systems, they implemented CashAnalytics, gaining efficiency and improving cash visibility for under $100k annually.

Optimal Treasury Team Size

The size of your treasury team also influences system selection. Specialized platforms for larger treasury departments provide functionality for complex global programs and users. Systems tailored for smaller teams focus more on ease of use and automation.

Large Treasury Teams

• FIS Quantum TMS
• Kyriba Enterprise Platform
• Murex MX.3

Small Treasury Teams

• CashAnalytics
• TreasuryXpress
• Cashforce Quantum

Carefully evaluating key elements like business model, global footprint, and team size allows for better alignment of needs to TMS solutions. This enables long term scalability and return on investment.

Treasury Software Trends and Innovations

As the financial landscape evolves, treasury management systems must keep pace with emerging innovations to stay competitive. Key technology trends shaping modern treasury software include:

Transition to Cloud-Based Systems

Cloud computing has become essential for agile and scalable treasury operations. Leading providers like Kyriba, IT2 Treasury, and Quantum offer secure SaaS platforms for centralized treasury management across global business units.

Cloud systems enable real-time cash visibility, automated reconciliations, seamless upgrades, and mobile accessibility. They eliminate the need for on-premises infrastructure, lowering TCO by over 30%. Integrations with ERPs like SAP, Oracle, and NetSuite simplify core financial processes.

According to Gartner, over 50% of treasurers will use SaaS treasury workstations by 2025, with the highest growth in banking, insurance, and manufacturing sectors.

Application Programming Interfaces

Open APIs allow treasury software to connect with external systems for streamlined data sharing. With API-enabled integrations, transactions from banking portals, ERPs, PoS terminals etc. can post directly into the TMS. This eliminates manual efforts, minimizes errors, and promotes straight-through processing.

Built-in APIs also facilitate customizations like adding proprietary models into the treasury workspace. Open connectivity through REST APIs and middleware enables legacy modernization initiatives.

As per Deloitte Insights, standardized APIs will be a prerequisite for treasury tech across industries by 2023.

Advanced Analytics and Business Intelligence

Sophisticated analytics help corporate treasurers gain meaningful insights from financial data for data-driven decisions. Modern systems provide intuitive reporting, customizable dashboards, and self-service BI tools without dependency on IT teams.

Using techniques like predictive analytics, blockchain-based fraud detection, and cash flow forecasting with ML algorithms, TMS analytics continues to evolve rapidly. For instance, Kyriba offers out-of-the-box integration with analytics platforms like Microsoft Power BI.

According to an AFP survey, 97% of treasurers believe using financial data for strategic insights will be a priority by 2025. Analytics-focused systems will be key enablers.

Enhanced Cybersecurity and Controls

With growing cyber threats, securing treasury data via encryption, access controls, and routine auditing protocols is now prerequisite. Leading providers use best practices like role-based access, MFA, key rotation, vaulted credentials, and automated anomaly detection to enable security by design.

Regulations like SOX mandate internal controls for financial reporting. Cloud-based treasury platforms streamline audits and compliance enforcement without additional middleware.

As per a Deloitte survey, bolstering cyber defense and internal controls tops technology investment priorities for corporate treasuries in 2023.

Wrapping Up: The Future of Financial Management

As we have seen, treasury management software continues to evolve rapidly to meet the changing needs of modern finance teams. Key players like Kyriba, Fusion Treasury, and Oracle provide robust platforms to centralize treasury operations, cash management, payments, risk mitigation, and more.

While legacy providers like Kyriba and Oracle offer stability from established vendors, newer entrants like Fusion Treasury are building agile cloud-based systems designed specifically for the realities of today's disruptive business environment. As a result, they may be better positioned to enable the digital transformation vital for many organizations.

Ultimately, the "best" treasury management system depends on your unique priorities and use cases. Larger enterprises may benefit from Oracle's scale and legacy capabilities, while smaller firms can leverage Fusion Treasury's flexibility and rapid iteration. Regardless, the next generation of treasury tech seems poised to deliver on the promise of centralized financial operations, actionable insights, and streamlined productivity.

As financial technologies continue maturing, we can expect treasury management platforms to expand automation, integrate complex data, and support predictive analytics for improved decision-making. While challenges remain around legacy processes, data silos, and cloud security, the future looks bright for centralized treasury teams equipped with the right tools for the job.

Related posts

• Top Financial Planning Software: A Detailed Review
• Choosing the Best International Tax Software
• Top Loan Servicing Software for Accounting Firms
• Top 5 Accounting Software: A Comprehensive Review